Showing posts with label conferences. Show all posts
Showing posts with label conferences. Show all posts

Saturday, November 23, 2013

How to Write a Panel Proposal

(a continuation of the discussion of conference proposals from yesterday)

So you’ve got an idea for a panel at an upcoming conference.  Now what?

Think carefully about how to frame the topic of the panel.  The topic should be of interest to more than just the people on the panel.  You want to propose your panel in way that signals to the section chair:  this panel will attract an audience.  The topic needs to be narrow enough that there is a reason to have a panel, but not so narrow that no one wants to show up.

Find participants.  You may already have some friends working on this topic, or you may have in mind some people you have never met but would like to.  Send them an email and ask them if they would be interested in a panel on your topic.  The earlier you email potential participants, the better.  Especially as people become more senior, they get more and more requests to be on panels.  If you wait until the last minute, they may not be available.
Also, if you’ve never emailed someone out of the blue to ask them to be on a panel, keep this in mind:  people usually love when they are asked.  First, it is flattering (hey!  Someone knows who I am!).  Second, and even more important, you are saving them the trouble of having to organize a panel themselves.  It’s a win-win.  You will get turned down from time to time, but if you start early, I think you will be surprised at how often people will say yes.

Find paper authors first.  Chances are, when you ask Famous Theorist X to be on your panel, she will say something like, “I am not working on that topic anymore, but I would be happy to be chair for the panel.”  This is a Very Good Thing, even if it feels disappointing.  A lot of the people you first approach won’t be interested in presenting papers, but will be happy to serve as chairs or discussants.  So, start asking people to write papers first (these are the harder slots to fill), and you will likely end up with a chair and a discussant without even trying!

Try to submit as full a panel as you can, but submit what you've got.
  • Ideally, you want a “full” proposal:  one that includes a chair, 1-2 discussants, and 4-5 papers.  A full proposal is ideal because the section chair is less likely to tinker with your panel by adding on random papers that she thinks fit the theme.

  • As a minimum, you should have four people:  1 chair/discussant (double-duty), and 3 paper authors.  Anything less than that is not really a panel proposal.

  • If you have an idea for a panel, but say you have three great papers and no chair/discussant, or just two papers looking for a companion, then try this:  submit the paper proposals, and then email the section chairs you submitted them to, and let them know about the panel you think could be created around these papers.  If the section chairs know to look out for a possible panel on a theme, you may get the panel you wanted anyhow.

Think about variety and seniority when composing the panel.
  • Do not propose a panel of you and your grad school friends who all hang out at the same bar on Friday night.  Nobody wants to go to the panel whose participants all have the exact same institutional affiliation.  And you want to network and meet other people, right?  So diversify.

  • Find people with different approaches to the same topic.  You do not need to have diametrically opposed viewpoints (although that can be fun), but audiences want to see some alternatives, some provocation, some drama.  Give the people what they want.  If the panelists are all in agreement with one another, it will be dull, dull, dull.

  • If the paper authors are all relatively junior (i.e. grad students, recent PhDs, junior faculty), then try to get someone to serve as discussant or chair who has a bit more seniority and star power.  That person will help attract an audience for your work (a good thing!), and will also lend the proposal some credibility in case the section chair is wondering about it.  Think of this as like a celebrity endorsement.

Edit the individual paper proposals to fit together.
  • First, ask each of the authors to submit to you a 250-word abstract at least a week before the final proposal is due.

  • The abstracts you get will be of varying length and quality (not to mention punctuality).  They will also use different language.  You can make them more consistent with one another and with the panel by suggesting revisions and clarifications to the authors as you think warranted.

  • Edit all of the paper abstracts to roughly the same length.  I say 250 words per paper.  There is no need to go on about individual papers in a panel proposal.

Write a separate panel abstract explaining the panel as a whole.
The abstract for the panel can and should be longer than the individual paper proposals – I would aim for somewhere between 250 and 500 words.  It should include (in some order):

  • what is the topic of the panel
  • why does the topic matter (to anyone other than the panelists)
  • how does each paper add something important and unique to the panel
Here’s an example I just made up:
This panel explores the reception history of Simone de Beauvoir’s The Second Sex.  Intellectual historians are beginning to appreciate the importance of studying how the same text is received in different cultural contexts.  This panel contributes to that burgeoning literature by analyzing the impact of The Second Sex in different feminist movements around the world.  Author W looks at the reception in the U.S., Author X looks at Great Britain, Author Y at Brazil, and Author Z at the Soviet Union.
This is hardly a great proposal – yet.  But it illustrates the idea.

Choose Your Panel Title Wisely
Section chairs get to read the full panel proposal.  But conference attendees will only see the panel title.  If you want to attract an audience, think carefully about what you put in your title.  A clever phrase or quotation might seem like a good idea – to someone who gets to read the full proposal.  But it might make no sense on its own.  Go for descriptive titles that signal to your audience why they should care to attend your panel, instead of going to some other panel, or heading to the bar.

Thursday, November 21, 2013

How to Write a Conference Proposal

APSA proposal season is upon us, so I thought I would take some time to consider how to write a conference proposal.  There is a lot of mystery around the process of how to write a proposal that actually gets accepted.  I cannot say that I have mastered it myself, but I can at least share with you some of the secrets of crafting a proposal that is more likely to get accepted.

Roughly speaking, this is how the process works (at least for conferences like APSA, MPSA, WPSA, SPSA – APT is a little different):
  • People submit a combination of paper proposals and panel proposals through websites to specific sections at the conference.
  • The section chair receives all of the proposals at once sometime AFTER the deadline has passed.  [In other words, there is no advantage to submitting early.]
  • The section chair has a set number of panels for her section.
  • The section chair then fills those panel slots through a combination of accepting panel proposals, and crafting panels from individual paper proposals.

The acceptance rate varies tremendously from one conference to the next, and from one section to the next.  For the Foundations of Political Thought section at APSA, the acceptance rate is somewhere around 18%.  When I chaired the Political Philosophy:  Approaches and Themes section at MPSA in 2007, the acceptance rate was close to 100%.

This leads us to the Golden Rule of Conference Proposals:

The more selective the section,
the more you need to think like a section chair
in order to write a successful proposal.

So let’s take a trip into the mind of a section chair.  Section chairs for larger conferences will receive hundreds of proposals.  Reading these can become mind-numbingly dull.  Making decisions about which great proposals to accept and which great proposals to reject can be excruciating.  Here are the kinds of questions a section chair might ask while looking at these proposals:
  • Do I get what this paper/panel is about?  If I cannot understand the proposal, then I have to wonder whether the author will be able to write a paper or give a presentation that will make sense to the audience.

  • Is there an audience for this paper/panel?  One of the best kept secrets of conferences is that attendance at panels matters.  Sections often are allocated panel slots based on attendance at panels in the previous year.  So section chairs consider which papers and panels will be interesting to the kind of theorists who typically attend that conference.  They want to accept proposals that will attract numbers.

  • Which proposals make my job easier?  Remember that section chairs are often considering hundreds of proposals.  This is a TON of work in and of itself, just reading and evaluating the different papers and panels.  It takes even more work to try to cobble together a panel from the hundreds of individual paper proposals, and then to try to cajole friends into chairing and discussing.  Section chairs are often more likely to accept a panel proposal than a paper proposal for the simple reason that it saves them the hassle of having to put together a panel themselves.

All that said, there are section chairs who adopt decision rules to make their jobs easier, and you simply cannot predict who will adopt which rules.  Some will rule out individual paper proposals by graduate students; others will make it a point to include graduate students on the program.  Some will only consider panel proposals; others will make it a point to make room for panels that they put together.  Some will leave panel proposals untouched – the panel gets accepted or rejected as a whole; others will break up panel proposals to reject weak papers, to add in individual paper proposals that fit with the panel, or to create new panels that they think will be even better.   There’s no way to predict how a section chair will make these kinds of calls in advance – so don’t write your proposal with these kinds of issues in mind.  Just focus on the three questions above.

So, given what the mind of a section chair is like in general, here are some tips for writing conference proposals:

  • Write clearly.  Do not use unnecessary jargon.  Your ideas need to come across quickly to someone who is reading through hundreds and hundreds of proposals.
  • Write succinctly.  Sometimes the conference websites enforce a word or character limit, which is great because it forces proposals to be short.  But where the limit is not enforced by technology, you should enforce it for yourself.  A proposal that rambles on suggests an author who will submit a 70-page manifesto to her discussant and won’t be able to stick to a 12-minute presentation.  Shorter is better.
  • Write confidently.  Proposals are due so far in advance of the actual conference that you may not know yet what you will actually conclude, and you may not even be certain of the texts or questions you will be writing about.  That’s okay.  Write as if you are 100% certain of what you are doing.
  • Motivate the section chair to care about your paper.  Explain in your proposal why people should care about reopening a debate about the place of some obscure text that interests you.  Tell why the issue/author/book/policy matters.  This will help the section chair to see your proposal as one that could attract an audience.
  • Propose a panel.  Try to organize a full panel, instead of just proposing a paper.  Your proposal is more likely to be accepted, and it is also a chance for you to expand your network.
  • Choose the sections you submit to carefully.  You usually have the choice of submitting to two sections.  You can learn which sections are most likely to be appropriate for your proposal by looking at past conference programs online.  [One of the most common mistakes I see from younger theorists is when they idealistically submit their proposals to sections in comparative, IR, or American, thinking (rightly) that their work is relevant to those fields, but actually making it extremely unlikely that they will get accepted.  When possible, submit only to theory sections and sections that have a clear track record of accepting theory proposals.]

Lastly, a few words for graduate students:
  • Do not propose a dissertation prospectus.  A prospectus makes for a really terrible conference paper.  It is a proposal, not yet an argument.

  • Especially if you are early in the dissertation process (i.e. you have completed two or fewer chapters), I recommend that you only submit paper proposals for papers you have already written.  It may be tempting to propose the chapter you plan to write in the next few months.  But until you have more experience at conferences, I recommend that you stick with papers that are more polished and have had a round of feedback from your committee.  You will be more likely to give a good presentation, and to get helpful feedback from your discussant and audience when your work is more finished than preliminary.
 

If any of you have other thoughts on the proposal process, please email me or leave comments here!  I’m curious to hear what your experience has been, and what you would advise.