Showing posts with label for mentors. Show all posts
Showing posts with label for mentors. Show all posts

Thursday, January 16, 2014

my six-month check in

I've been mentoring now for about six months, and I thought with the start of a new semester this would be a good time to reflect on what has been working and what has not.  I want to share my reflections as a part of my aspiration to generate conversations about mentoring in our field.  I'd love to hear what you have learned about mentoring, too, whether you've been a mentor or a mentee - or both.  Leave a comment below or send me an email.  (You can post a comment anonymously!)


What have I learned in the last six months?

  • I really didn't need to know as much about mentoring as I thought I did.  At first, I was scouring the web looking for information about how to mentor.  There really isn't much information out there, but I don't think that made much of a difference.  I've still been able to do something that I think is of benefit to my mentees.  As usual, I'm going to insist that this is good news for all of you potential or actual mentors out there:  you can do it!

  • Rather than working consistently on the long-term goals we set in our first conversation, my mentees often have new questions and issues to work through each time we talk.  There is no way for me to anticipate what questions they will have for me, or what they will want to discuss.  It might be about conferences, writing, the job market, publishing, colleagues, advisers, family, etc.  On the one hand, this means that we always have lots to talk about (something I worried about at first).  On the other hand, this means that the important and immediate issues are often getting in the way of working on the important and long-term issues.  I want to work on strategies to make sure the important but long-term stuff does not simply fall by the wayside.

  • My mentees often seem to feel they should only make use of me when they have an immediate problem.  I've tried setting up monthly check-ins to counteract this:  so they know they always have a chance to check in.  I think I should do a better job of communicating with them that we are working on both their immediate concerns and the long-term goals we set at the beginning of the relationship.

  • I am struggling with finding the balance between giving advice and showing them that they have the wisdom and the skills to answer their own questions.  I am not sure yet what that balance should look like, but I do worry that I have crossed over sometimes onto the "telling my mentee what to do" side of the street.  Something to keep an eye on.


I've also learned some qualities necessary to a successful mentorship:
  1. voluntariness - both mentor and mentee should choose the relationship.  (I've seen a lot of attempts at mentoring fail because one party or the other wasn't clear on why they were doing this.  I think mentees, especially, need to choose to have mentors.)
  2. confidentiality/safety - it is essential that the mentee be able to trust the mentor.  This, I think is crucial when mentorship is happening among persons in the same department or institution.  But I think it is important in all mentoring relationships.
  3. structure - mentors need to provide some kind of leadership in the relationship, giving mentees a bit of structure to work with - especially at the beginning.  Mentoring programs that give mentors no instruction (I'm looking at you, APSA!) are less likely to be successful, because they are more dependent on individual mentors having more or less good instincts. It has been particularly discouraging to me to hear stories from people who have signed up for the APSA mentoring program and had bad experiences.  Let's change that!
  4. persistence - mentors especially need to be persistent about following up with mentees (especially those who are diffident and/or at earlier career stages).  I'm going to go out on a limb here and assert that it is not a good mentoring practice to simply wait for the mentee to get in touch.  At least not at the beginning of a relationship.

Wednesday, November 20, 2013

Celebrate everything. Every. little. thing.


To reach the most important milestones in an academic career, we are dependent upon the approval of others:  getting the Ph.D., getting a tenure-track job, getting tenure, getting published.  How we relate to this dependency has a lot to do with how satisfied we are with our careers.

We might respond to this dependency by feeling powerless:  Other people have control over my fate; there is little or nothing I can do to affect the outcome.  I send my job applications out, and search committees control whether I even get an interview.  I send articles out to journals, yet I am at the mercy of reviewers.  I submit my dissertation to my committee members, but they get to decide whether my work is good enough to deserve the Ph.D. 

Or we might respond to this dependency by feeling resentment:  That reviewer had no business reviewing my article, because he clearly doesn’t know the first thing about John Dewey!  My dissertation advisor is washed up and can’t even come up with a good idea for her second book; who is she to judge my work?  Social scientists and scientists have no idea what goes into writing humanistic scholarship; their feedback on my tenure file is completely irrelevant.

A lot of academic unhappiness is caused when one or both of these responses become our dominant response to our career dependence on the approval of others.  Here’s how I think this works:

Powerlessness encourages insecurity about the value of one’s work, and bewilderment about how academia works.  You may have heard someone say:  “I have no idea how I got this job; I don’t know the first thing about how to advise anyone else on the job market.”  “I don’t know how I got that article published in Journal X.  It’s just luck, I guess.”  “My committee probably let me defend because they were tired of having me around.”  “I’m the admissions mistake.  I have no idea why they let me into this Ph.D. program.”  This kind of response to dependency produces academics who think that they are here by mistake or chance, who believe they cannot advise or mentor others effectively because they see their success as a matter of chance, and who are diffident about their own abilities, no matter what their accomplishments.

Resentment encourages seeing other people as obstacles to our success, rather than viewing them as collaborators, colleagues, and friends.  You may have encountered a resentful colleague who fails to contribute to department service, or who makes passive aggressive comments in meetings, or who tries to draw you into conspiracy theories about the people who are out to get her.  Often the resentful academic takes full credit for her successes, but blames her failures on others.  “That reviewer just didn’t get how brilliant my article is!”  “The dean is out to get me because he is jealous!”  “My colleagues are all second-rate hacks.  They wouldn’t know a great work of scholarship if it hit them in the face!”  This kind of response produces academics who cannot play well with others, who thrive on and magnify negative situations, and whose willingness to mentor and advise can often seem contingent upon whether they perceive you as friend or foe.

Now I’ve painted two extreme caricatures here to try to suggest how these two common responses to our dependency as academics can contribute to deep unhappiness and dissatisfaction with our careers.  Fortunately, these are not the only ways we might respond to this dependency.

 

What is the antidote to powerlessness and resentment?  Celebration.

Academia is short on celebration.  Our career goals are often very long-term:  earning a Ph.D., getting tenure, publishing a book, etc.  Not only is the outcome something over which we do not have control, it also is really far away.  If we constantly defer celebrating until we have the Ph.D., the tenure-track job, the published book, or tenure, it could literally be years between celebrations.  That’s pretty depressing, frankly.

Moreover, when all we do is celebrate the final outcome of a particular milestone, we are actually increasing our dependency on the approval of others.  If I can’t celebrate submitting my first dissertation draft to my committee because they might not agree that I am ready to defend, then I am giving my committee not just the power to award me the Ph.D., but also the power to tell me when I have done something worthy of celebration.  If I can’t celebrate sending my book manuscript out to presses for review, then I am giving the editor and the book reviewers not just the power to offer me a contract, but also the power to tell me when I have done something worthy of celebration. 

You get to decide when you have done something worthy of celebration.  And if I were you, I would celebrate everything.  Every. little. thing.  Why the heck not?

If you celebrate what you have accomplished now, you take some of the emphasis off of the final outcome.  Think of it this way:  if you celebrate finishing a manuscript, no one can take that celebration away.  Not even if the manuscript is rejected by the journal you really wanted to see publish it.  You may not have the publication you wanted, but at least you didn’t miss the opportunity to celebrate finishing the manuscript in the first place.

Plus, it makes academic life more enjoyable.  Otherwise, you could be waiting for years to celebrate.  And in the meantime, you may be on pins and needles, feeling too powerless or resentful of your dependency on the approval of others to genuinely appreciate your accomplishments.

Celebration can look like whatever you want it to look like.  It might be throwing a party, posting an update on facebook, taking a day off, going on a dream vacation, enjoying a movie, or calling a loved one to tell them the good news.  Celebration is whatever will feel like celebration to you.

Celebrate when you send out a manuscript.  Celebrate when you get a book contract.  Celebrate when you have a good day of writing or teaching.  Celebrate when you handle a rejection well.  And of course, celebrate when you get the first copy of the book, the final tenure letter, your Ph.D., and that job offer. 

Academic life is a lot more humane when you celebrate frequently.  And, it turns out, frequent celebration makes you a lot less dependent on others for their approval.  They will still be gatekeepers, of course, and you will still get rejections.  But by owning and celebrating your accomplishments along the way, you acknowledge that you are not entirely powerless over your fate, even if you cannot control it.  And by owning and acknowledging your accomplishments for yourself, you attenuate your dependence on the approval of others, which alleviates the tendency to resent them for failing to grant it.

 

So try this on.  What do you have to celebrate today?

Wednesday, October 16, 2013

are you my mentee?*

[Note:  This is a post for mentors.  The companion post for mentees is here.]

So you've gone to APSAnet, you've signed up to mentor, and you've just received an email telling you they've found a potential match.  Now what?

Don't rush into it.  Stop and assess whether you and your potential mentee are a good fit for one another.

You wouldn't marry the first person eharmony matched you up with, sight unseen, would you?  So don't rush into this, either.  Take the time to figure out if you and your potential mentee really do make a good match.

I suggest having a conversation - by phone, by email, in person at a conference - with your potential mentee to assess your fit.  What are some things you might consider?

  • your motivations for mentoring.  If you really want to mentor a junior colleague on a tenure track at a liberal arts college, and APSA set you up with a graduate student who wants to teach at an R1, would you still want to do this?  What if you want to mentor a female theorist, but APSA set you up with a female Americanist?  Or you want to support racial minorities, but APSA matched you with a white, gay man?  Would you rather pass and wait for a closer match to your interests?

  • your time vs. your mentee's needs.  If your mentee wants someone who can read drafts and talk frequently, do you really want to give them that much time?  How about a mentee just starting a tenure track, who wants occasional guidance for the next seven years until tenure time?  Think seriously about what you are willing to commit to, and how that fits with what your potential mentee wants. 

  • your ability to be a good mentor to this particular person.  If your potential mentee is writing a dissertation with your best friend or your ex as their advisor, will you really be the best person to offer her guidance?  If your potential mentee works in the exact same research area as you, would you be depriving her of your ability to be an external letter writer for tenure, or to be a reviewer for her book manuscript?

Even if you are really enthusiastic about mentoring this particular person, by slowing things down and giving your potential mentee a chance to reflect on her needs and expectations, you are modeling for her a very important skill:  the ability to be very intentional about forming professional relationships.

--------------------

*I am indebted to Sheryl Sandberg for this blogpost title, which is a play on her insightful chapter in Lean In, entitled "Are You My Mentor?"