Showing posts with label what is mentoring. Show all posts
Showing posts with label what is mentoring. Show all posts

Thursday, January 16, 2014

my six-month check in

I've been mentoring now for about six months, and I thought with the start of a new semester this would be a good time to reflect on what has been working and what has not.  I want to share my reflections as a part of my aspiration to generate conversations about mentoring in our field.  I'd love to hear what you have learned about mentoring, too, whether you've been a mentor or a mentee - or both.  Leave a comment below or send me an email.  (You can post a comment anonymously!)


What have I learned in the last six months?

  • I really didn't need to know as much about mentoring as I thought I did.  At first, I was scouring the web looking for information about how to mentor.  There really isn't much information out there, but I don't think that made much of a difference.  I've still been able to do something that I think is of benefit to my mentees.  As usual, I'm going to insist that this is good news for all of you potential or actual mentors out there:  you can do it!

  • Rather than working consistently on the long-term goals we set in our first conversation, my mentees often have new questions and issues to work through each time we talk.  There is no way for me to anticipate what questions they will have for me, or what they will want to discuss.  It might be about conferences, writing, the job market, publishing, colleagues, advisers, family, etc.  On the one hand, this means that we always have lots to talk about (something I worried about at first).  On the other hand, this means that the important and immediate issues are often getting in the way of working on the important and long-term issues.  I want to work on strategies to make sure the important but long-term stuff does not simply fall by the wayside.

  • My mentees often seem to feel they should only make use of me when they have an immediate problem.  I've tried setting up monthly check-ins to counteract this:  so they know they always have a chance to check in.  I think I should do a better job of communicating with them that we are working on both their immediate concerns and the long-term goals we set at the beginning of the relationship.

  • I am struggling with finding the balance between giving advice and showing them that they have the wisdom and the skills to answer their own questions.  I am not sure yet what that balance should look like, but I do worry that I have crossed over sometimes onto the "telling my mentee what to do" side of the street.  Something to keep an eye on.


I've also learned some qualities necessary to a successful mentorship:
  1. voluntariness - both mentor and mentee should choose the relationship.  (I've seen a lot of attempts at mentoring fail because one party or the other wasn't clear on why they were doing this.  I think mentees, especially, need to choose to have mentors.)
  2. confidentiality/safety - it is essential that the mentee be able to trust the mentor.  This, I think is crucial when mentorship is happening among persons in the same department or institution.  But I think it is important in all mentoring relationships.
  3. structure - mentors need to provide some kind of leadership in the relationship, giving mentees a bit of structure to work with - especially at the beginning.  Mentoring programs that give mentors no instruction (I'm looking at you, APSA!) are less likely to be successful, because they are more dependent on individual mentors having more or less good instincts. It has been particularly discouraging to me to hear stories from people who have signed up for the APSA mentoring program and had bad experiences.  Let's change that!
  4. persistence - mentors especially need to be persistent about following up with mentees (especially those who are diffident and/or at earlier career stages).  I'm going to go out on a limb here and assert that it is not a good mentoring practice to simply wait for the mentee to get in touch.  At least not at the beginning of a relationship.

Tuesday, October 15, 2013

Mentoring is Planned Obsolescence


What do mentors do?
A lot of us who have never experienced good mentoring may have no idea what a mentor actually does.  In a future post, I will debunk some of the myths of mentoring.  For today, I want to offer some thoughts on what good mentors do, to show you that mentoring is absolutely something you can do.  (As always, if you want to try your hand at it, go to APSAnet and sign up!)

Good mentoring is all about planned obsolescence.  The purpose of a mentor is to become unnecessary to the mentee.  Think of it as like good parenting:  you want your child to grow up to be an adult who is not dependent on you anymore, but who knows when and how to call on you if they want your help.

Mentors help mentees to meet three kinds of need, with the goal of guiding mentees to be independent of the mentor.

Mentee Need #1:  Addressing Practical Concerns

This is probably what most people think of when they think of mentoring.  Depending on the mentee’s stage, practical concerns might include:
  • The job market:  writing cover letters, doing interviews, organizing a CV, the ethics of going on the market while already employed
  • Publications:  where to submit articles, how to respond to readers’ reports, how to write a book prospectus
  • Time management:  how to make research progress while teaching full-time, how to make the most of research leave
  • Teaching:  how to deal with problems in the classroom, how to design a syllabus, how to improve teaching skills
  • Tenure:  how to put together tenure file materials, how to strategize publications for tenure

Mentors can either offer advice to their mentees directly, or encourage their mentees to seek advice from other sources.  There is no reason why a mentor needs to be an expert in a given area in order to mentor effectively:  a good mentor needs only to be able to point the mentee towards resources or people who can help them to get appropriate advice.  This brings us to the second need:

Mentee Need #2:  Developing a Broader Network

Most mentees will likely not identify this as one of their needs at first, but helping a mentee to develop a broader network is actually the way that a good mentor makes herself obsolete. 

It is highly unlikely that as a mentor you will be able to answer all of your mentee’s questions.  Nor should you, since the idea here is to gradually decrease your mentee’s reliance on you.  For example, if you are mentoring someone at a different institution, there will be institution-specific context you will not have or understand.  In such a case, you will want to help your mentee to identify people and resources at their campus that can help them to get the institution-specific guidance they need.  You might even encourage them to take on multiple mentors, some on campus, some off.

In some cases, mentors can help mentees build a network by introducing them to people they themselves know. However, this is not the primary way in which a mentor helps a mentee to build a broader network.  What it is really about is helping the mentee to identify for herself who she might turn to for support, advice, and/or mentoring – always with an eye towards her ultimately being able to get on without you altogether.

Mentee Need #3:  Transitioning to a New Career Stage

Graduate student mentees are in the process of transitioning from being students to seeing themselves as scholars and (ultimately) professors.  Junior faculty mentees are in the process of transitioning from being early career scholars to seeing themselves as senior scholars in the field.  The transitional needs mentees have will be very individual, and often quite personal.  This is an area of mentorship that some people will likely enjoy quite a bit, whereas others will not want to get quite so personal with their mentees.  It’s a good idea to be aware of whether you want to help your mentee address these kinds of needs or not.

The kind of things I am thinking of here have to do with a transition in one’s identity.  For one mentee, this may entail work on developing the self-confidence needed to fully embody a new role as a Ph.D., as a professor, or as an expert in a particular area of scholarship.  For another mentee, this might come out in terms of discussions about the relationship between personal and professional lives:  new career stages often involve moving away (literally and figuratively) from loved ones, or dealing with new relationship/family/career stresses, or the loneliness of a new institution and a new city.

So what do mentors do?

What mentors do is help mentees to meet some combination of these three needs.  As a mentor, you can decide for yourself whether you want to address all of these areas, or just a subset of them.  This may seem daunting – but just remember, a big part of being a mentor is helping your mentee to develop a network of supporters and mentors that extends well beyond you.  So if any of this seems beyond your reach, that’s actually good news:  that’s an area in which you already know your role will be to help your mentee to find someone else to support them.  By knowing your own limits, you are well on your way to planned obsolescence!