Wednesday, November 6, 2013

How to mentor for tenure from the outside in

[Note:  This is a post for mentors of junior faculty on a tenure-track.  The companion post for junior faculty mentees is here.]

One of the challenges of taking on a mentee who is not at your own institution is that you lack insider's information about how your mentee's institution works.  This is especially challenging in the case of mentoring junior faculty who are working towards tenure.  Tenure expectations, procedures, and norms vary widely from one place to the next.  Understandably, external mentors may feel unqualified to help their mentees navigate the idiosyncrasies of the tenure process at their home institutions.

However, external mentors can play a very important role in helping their mentees to collect information about how tenure and promotion work at their own colleges or universities.


Here's how this works: 

It is a rare department or school that has very clear, written expectations for tenure and promotion.  For example, some departments give junior faculty a specific number of peer-reviewed journals that they must publish, and even give them a list of journals in which they must publish.  In such cases, there may be no room for exceptions, but also no room for misinterpretation of what the standards are.

But in most cases, tenure and promotion expectations are pretty vague.  What is an "excellent" versus a "satisfactory" teaching record?  Do book chapters count if they are peer-reviewed?  Is it acceptable to publish a book with a relatively obscure press, if the book appears with a series that is prestigious in one's area; or is it better to publish with a more generally recognized press?  Does service require more than just serving on committees to which one has been assigned?  Is outreach valued, or regarded as an unnecessary distraction from research productivity?  Does the department recognize that theorists' research productivity often looks quite different from that of other political scientists?

The reality of tenure and promotion is this:  many, many individuals sit in judgment on our files, each of whom may have her own take on what counts as excellence in different areas of our work.  Not only is there institutional variation, but there is individual variation as well.  It is dangerous, therefore, to plan for tenure based on what any one individual says the expectations are - because that person is just one of many who may have a say in the process!


So, here's how you can help your mentee navigate the vagueness of the tenure process: 

1.  Assess what she already knows about tenure and promotion at her institution. 

Ask questions like:
  • How often are you reviewed before going up for tenure?  What are the expectations for these pre-tenure reviews?  For research?  Teaching?  Service?

  • What are the expectations for tenure?  For research?  Teaching?  Service?

2.  Now assess how much information she has gathered about tenure and promotion at her institution. 

Ask questions like:
  • How do you know that these are the expectations for pre-tenure and tenure review at your institutions?

  • Who have you talked with in your department about these expectations?

  • Who have you talked with outside your department about these expectations?

In some cases, you may discover that your mentee has very good information:  she has examined written documents about the process, she has spoken with a lot of people in and outside her department. 

In other cases, you may discover that your mentee is relying on information from just a few people - perhaps the chair of the department, or a senior theorist.  In such cases, you can encourage your mentee to cast her net more widely and strike up conversations about tenure expectations with more people. 

And - bonus! - you've just helped her to broaden her mentoring network by asking more people at her own institution to fill her in on the process.  You've turned a negative (your lack of knowledge about her institution) into a positive (an opportunity for her to become less dependent on you).


----------------

I'm curious:  how does this fit with your experience of the tenure process?  Are there other specific questions you would want your mentee to ask?  How did you get information about tenure and promotion when you were junior?  Send me an email or leave me a comment!

No comments:

Post a Comment