Wednesday, December 4, 2013

How to Use this Blog to Self-Mentor

So you’d like to mentor yourself?  Maybe you don’t want a mentor, or you are waiting for APSA to match you with a mentor, or you have a mentor but are looking for additional resources.  Fabulous.  Here’s how to use this blog to mentor yourself:
 

Mentoring is about addressing three kinds of needs that we all have in periods of career transition.  Identify a specific need that you are looking to address, and then scan over to the right of this screen to the list of Posts by Topic.  Each post is tagged with labels to help you quickly identify posts that will be most useful to you, given your needs.

So what are these three kinds of needs?

Mentee Need #1:  Addressing Practical Concerns
This is probably what most people think of when they think of mentoring.  Practical concerns might include:

  • The job market:  writing cover letters, doing interviews, organizing a CV, the ethics of going on the market while already employed
  • Publications:  where to submit articles, how to respond to readers’ reports, how to write a book prospectus
  • Time management:  how to make research progress while teaching full-time, how to make the most of research leave
  • Teaching:  how to deal with problems in the classroom, how to design a syllabus, how to improve teaching skills
  • Tenure:  how to put together tenure file materials, how to strategize publications for tenure

If you have a practical concern, look for a tag at the right with a related title.  If you don’t see a tag with the topic you want support with, then email me or leave a comment to let me know.  Since this blog is relatively new, there will be a lot of topics that do not have any related posts just yet.  But I will get there over time – and your gentle nudge will let me know where there is most need.

 
Mentee Need #2:  Developing a Broader Network

A lot of people will likely not identify this as one of their needs at first, but this is absolutely crucial to a successful career, happiness in life, and world peace.  Plus, this is a way to find people who can mentor you!    

For this need, I’ve got a few important posts already up and running for you.  Just click on “networking” over on the right.

 
Mentee Need #3:  Transitioning to a New Career Stage

This is the need, I believe, that is the most difficult to meet when we are doing it all by ourselves.  So, while I want to set up resources for you to self-mentor using this blog, I also want to encourage you to still find yourself a flesh and blood mentor (or two or three).

The kind of things I am thinking of here have to do with a transition in one’s identity.  For one person, this may entail work on developing the self-confidence needed to fully embody a new role as a Ph.D., as a professor, or as an expert in a particular area of scholarship.  For another person, this might involve concerns about the relationship between personal and professional lives:  new career stages often involve moving away (literally and figuratively) from loved ones, or dealing with new relationship/family/career stresses, or the loneliness of a new institution and a new city.

I do not yet have any resources up about how to work on transitions, but I intend to develop these (and then label them “transitions” for you over on the right).
 
 
 
Alright, get to it!  Mentor yourself!

Tuesday, November 26, 2013

Six Obstacles to Writing

We encounter many obstacles to writing, some of which we can do nothing about (catching a cold, getting into a car accident, having to teach during our prime writing hours).  But there are other obstacles that we can do something about, and I'd like to reflect on some of those today.

These are internal obstacles - recurring thoughts that slow us down or even paralyze us.  They get in the way of writing.

It turns out that every writer experiences these obstacles.  Some of us might experience some of these more often than others.  But we all will experience each of these at some point.

The trouble is when we believe these thoughts to be true about us as authors.

So the antidote to these recurring thoughts?  Try experiencing these obstacles as part of the writing process.  They occur to every writer, they are not unique to you.  They are part of the structure, the texture of writing.  And they will pass eventually if you can acknowledge them and let them go.

Here are the six obstacles, along with some examples.  You may recognize yourself in these examples, or there might be different ways these obstacles show up for you.  Get to know which ones are most likely to get in the way of your writing, and get to know how they manifest in your life.  When they show up, you can name them for what they are, notice them, and then gently let them go.


1.  Anxiety:  This is when you do not believe you can write now. 
Examples:            

  • I don’t have enough time today to write properly, so I won’t start now.
  • My ideas aren't good enough, polished enough, ready.
  • I am not inspired right now; I have to wait for my muse!


2.  Jealousy:  This is when you think other people can write, but you can’t.

Examples:           
  • X can write because she doesn’t have to deal with kids/stress/etc.
  • X has it so much easier than me, because of her background/mentoring/etc.
  • Writing just comes naturally to X; I have to struggle to write!


3.  Forgetfulness:  This is when you are so busy that you forget to make time to write.

Examples:           
  • I have all these urgent deadlines; I can’t write until after I am done with these.
  • You get to the end of an exhausting day, and you realize you haven’t spent any time writing – but why start now?



4.      Arrogance:  This is when you turn your self-doubt into a justification for not writing.
Examples:           
  • I don’t need to write now; I do my best writing at the last minute.
  • I’m so clever, I don’t need to waste my time writing every day like others do.
  • I’m an experienced writer, so I don’t need to practice writing anymore.



5.  Criticism:  This is when you blame people and things external to you to justify not writing.
Examples:           
  • I can’t write because of those noisy people who keep distracting me from work!
  • The real problem is this stupid deadline: who decided on this date anyway?
  • It’s ridiculous that I have to write this abstract/personal statement/proposal!
 

6.      Body & Mind Out of Sync:  This is when you get so caught in your thinking and your doubts that you neglect your body.

Examples:           
  • I have to pull an all-nighter in order to get this done; I don’t really need to sleep.
  • I can’t afford to take a break – I have to keep writing, or else I will lose steam!
  • I don’t have time to exercise/eat/go to the bathroom – being a good writer is all about self-sacrifice.
 

(I am indebted to my meditation teachers for these insights into my writing practice; these obstacles are loosely adapted from descriptions of obstacles to meditation in numerous Buddhist texts.)

Saturday, November 23, 2013

How to Write a Panel Proposal

(a continuation of the discussion of conference proposals from yesterday)

So you’ve got an idea for a panel at an upcoming conference.  Now what?

Think carefully about how to frame the topic of the panel.  The topic should be of interest to more than just the people on the panel.  You want to propose your panel in way that signals to the section chair:  this panel will attract an audience.  The topic needs to be narrow enough that there is a reason to have a panel, but not so narrow that no one wants to show up.

Find participants.  You may already have some friends working on this topic, or you may have in mind some people you have never met but would like to.  Send them an email and ask them if they would be interested in a panel on your topic.  The earlier you email potential participants, the better.  Especially as people become more senior, they get more and more requests to be on panels.  If you wait until the last minute, they may not be available.
Also, if you’ve never emailed someone out of the blue to ask them to be on a panel, keep this in mind:  people usually love when they are asked.  First, it is flattering (hey!  Someone knows who I am!).  Second, and even more important, you are saving them the trouble of having to organize a panel themselves.  It’s a win-win.  You will get turned down from time to time, but if you start early, I think you will be surprised at how often people will say yes.

Find paper authors first.  Chances are, when you ask Famous Theorist X to be on your panel, she will say something like, “I am not working on that topic anymore, but I would be happy to be chair for the panel.”  This is a Very Good Thing, even if it feels disappointing.  A lot of the people you first approach won’t be interested in presenting papers, but will be happy to serve as chairs or discussants.  So, start asking people to write papers first (these are the harder slots to fill), and you will likely end up with a chair and a discussant without even trying!

Try to submit as full a panel as you can, but submit what you've got.
  • Ideally, you want a “full” proposal:  one that includes a chair, 1-2 discussants, and 4-5 papers.  A full proposal is ideal because the section chair is less likely to tinker with your panel by adding on random papers that she thinks fit the theme.

  • As a minimum, you should have four people:  1 chair/discussant (double-duty), and 3 paper authors.  Anything less than that is not really a panel proposal.

  • If you have an idea for a panel, but say you have three great papers and no chair/discussant, or just two papers looking for a companion, then try this:  submit the paper proposals, and then email the section chairs you submitted them to, and let them know about the panel you think could be created around these papers.  If the section chairs know to look out for a possible panel on a theme, you may get the panel you wanted anyhow.

Think about variety and seniority when composing the panel.
  • Do not propose a panel of you and your grad school friends who all hang out at the same bar on Friday night.  Nobody wants to go to the panel whose participants all have the exact same institutional affiliation.  And you want to network and meet other people, right?  So diversify.

  • Find people with different approaches to the same topic.  You do not need to have diametrically opposed viewpoints (although that can be fun), but audiences want to see some alternatives, some provocation, some drama.  Give the people what they want.  If the panelists are all in agreement with one another, it will be dull, dull, dull.

  • If the paper authors are all relatively junior (i.e. grad students, recent PhDs, junior faculty), then try to get someone to serve as discussant or chair who has a bit more seniority and star power.  That person will help attract an audience for your work (a good thing!), and will also lend the proposal some credibility in case the section chair is wondering about it.  Think of this as like a celebrity endorsement.

Edit the individual paper proposals to fit together.
  • First, ask each of the authors to submit to you a 250-word abstract at least a week before the final proposal is due.

  • The abstracts you get will be of varying length and quality (not to mention punctuality).  They will also use different language.  You can make them more consistent with one another and with the panel by suggesting revisions and clarifications to the authors as you think warranted.

  • Edit all of the paper abstracts to roughly the same length.  I say 250 words per paper.  There is no need to go on about individual papers in a panel proposal.

Write a separate panel abstract explaining the panel as a whole.
The abstract for the panel can and should be longer than the individual paper proposals – I would aim for somewhere between 250 and 500 words.  It should include (in some order):

  • what is the topic of the panel
  • why does the topic matter (to anyone other than the panelists)
  • how does each paper add something important and unique to the panel
Here’s an example I just made up:
This panel explores the reception history of Simone de Beauvoir’s The Second Sex.  Intellectual historians are beginning to appreciate the importance of studying how the same text is received in different cultural contexts.  This panel contributes to that burgeoning literature by analyzing the impact of The Second Sex in different feminist movements around the world.  Author W looks at the reception in the U.S., Author X looks at Great Britain, Author Y at Brazil, and Author Z at the Soviet Union.
This is hardly a great proposal – yet.  But it illustrates the idea.

Choose Your Panel Title Wisely
Section chairs get to read the full panel proposal.  But conference attendees will only see the panel title.  If you want to attract an audience, think carefully about what you put in your title.  A clever phrase or quotation might seem like a good idea – to someone who gets to read the full proposal.  But it might make no sense on its own.  Go for descriptive titles that signal to your audience why they should care to attend your panel, instead of going to some other panel, or heading to the bar.

Thursday, November 21, 2013

How to Write a Conference Proposal

APSA proposal season is upon us, so I thought I would take some time to consider how to write a conference proposal.  There is a lot of mystery around the process of how to write a proposal that actually gets accepted.  I cannot say that I have mastered it myself, but I can at least share with you some of the secrets of crafting a proposal that is more likely to get accepted.

Roughly speaking, this is how the process works (at least for conferences like APSA, MPSA, WPSA, SPSA – APT is a little different):
  • People submit a combination of paper proposals and panel proposals through websites to specific sections at the conference.
  • The section chair receives all of the proposals at once sometime AFTER the deadline has passed.  [In other words, there is no advantage to submitting early.]
  • The section chair has a set number of panels for her section.
  • The section chair then fills those panel slots through a combination of accepting panel proposals, and crafting panels from individual paper proposals.

The acceptance rate varies tremendously from one conference to the next, and from one section to the next.  For the Foundations of Political Thought section at APSA, the acceptance rate is somewhere around 18%.  When I chaired the Political Philosophy:  Approaches and Themes section at MPSA in 2007, the acceptance rate was close to 100%.

This leads us to the Golden Rule of Conference Proposals:

The more selective the section,
the more you need to think like a section chair
in order to write a successful proposal.

So let’s take a trip into the mind of a section chair.  Section chairs for larger conferences will receive hundreds of proposals.  Reading these can become mind-numbingly dull.  Making decisions about which great proposals to accept and which great proposals to reject can be excruciating.  Here are the kinds of questions a section chair might ask while looking at these proposals:
  • Do I get what this paper/panel is about?  If I cannot understand the proposal, then I have to wonder whether the author will be able to write a paper or give a presentation that will make sense to the audience.

  • Is there an audience for this paper/panel?  One of the best kept secrets of conferences is that attendance at panels matters.  Sections often are allocated panel slots based on attendance at panels in the previous year.  So section chairs consider which papers and panels will be interesting to the kind of theorists who typically attend that conference.  They want to accept proposals that will attract numbers.

  • Which proposals make my job easier?  Remember that section chairs are often considering hundreds of proposals.  This is a TON of work in and of itself, just reading and evaluating the different papers and panels.  It takes even more work to try to cobble together a panel from the hundreds of individual paper proposals, and then to try to cajole friends into chairing and discussing.  Section chairs are often more likely to accept a panel proposal than a paper proposal for the simple reason that it saves them the hassle of having to put together a panel themselves.

All that said, there are section chairs who adopt decision rules to make their jobs easier, and you simply cannot predict who will adopt which rules.  Some will rule out individual paper proposals by graduate students; others will make it a point to include graduate students on the program.  Some will only consider panel proposals; others will make it a point to make room for panels that they put together.  Some will leave panel proposals untouched – the panel gets accepted or rejected as a whole; others will break up panel proposals to reject weak papers, to add in individual paper proposals that fit with the panel, or to create new panels that they think will be even better.   There’s no way to predict how a section chair will make these kinds of calls in advance – so don’t write your proposal with these kinds of issues in mind.  Just focus on the three questions above.

So, given what the mind of a section chair is like in general, here are some tips for writing conference proposals:

  • Write clearly.  Do not use unnecessary jargon.  Your ideas need to come across quickly to someone who is reading through hundreds and hundreds of proposals.
  • Write succinctly.  Sometimes the conference websites enforce a word or character limit, which is great because it forces proposals to be short.  But where the limit is not enforced by technology, you should enforce it for yourself.  A proposal that rambles on suggests an author who will submit a 70-page manifesto to her discussant and won’t be able to stick to a 12-minute presentation.  Shorter is better.
  • Write confidently.  Proposals are due so far in advance of the actual conference that you may not know yet what you will actually conclude, and you may not even be certain of the texts or questions you will be writing about.  That’s okay.  Write as if you are 100% certain of what you are doing.
  • Motivate the section chair to care about your paper.  Explain in your proposal why people should care about reopening a debate about the place of some obscure text that interests you.  Tell why the issue/author/book/policy matters.  This will help the section chair to see your proposal as one that could attract an audience.
  • Propose a panel.  Try to organize a full panel, instead of just proposing a paper.  Your proposal is more likely to be accepted, and it is also a chance for you to expand your network.
  • Choose the sections you submit to carefully.  You usually have the choice of submitting to two sections.  You can learn which sections are most likely to be appropriate for your proposal by looking at past conference programs online.  [One of the most common mistakes I see from younger theorists is when they idealistically submit their proposals to sections in comparative, IR, or American, thinking (rightly) that their work is relevant to those fields, but actually making it extremely unlikely that they will get accepted.  When possible, submit only to theory sections and sections that have a clear track record of accepting theory proposals.]

Lastly, a few words for graduate students:
  • Do not propose a dissertation prospectus.  A prospectus makes for a really terrible conference paper.  It is a proposal, not yet an argument.

  • Especially if you are early in the dissertation process (i.e. you have completed two or fewer chapters), I recommend that you only submit paper proposals for papers you have already written.  It may be tempting to propose the chapter you plan to write in the next few months.  But until you have more experience at conferences, I recommend that you stick with papers that are more polished and have had a round of feedback from your committee.  You will be more likely to give a good presentation, and to get helpful feedback from your discussant and audience when your work is more finished than preliminary.
 

If any of you have other thoughts on the proposal process, please email me or leave comments here!  I’m curious to hear what your experience has been, and what you would advise.

Wednesday, November 20, 2013

Celebrate everything. Every. little. thing.


To reach the most important milestones in an academic career, we are dependent upon the approval of others:  getting the Ph.D., getting a tenure-track job, getting tenure, getting published.  How we relate to this dependency has a lot to do with how satisfied we are with our careers.

We might respond to this dependency by feeling powerless:  Other people have control over my fate; there is little or nothing I can do to affect the outcome.  I send my job applications out, and search committees control whether I even get an interview.  I send articles out to journals, yet I am at the mercy of reviewers.  I submit my dissertation to my committee members, but they get to decide whether my work is good enough to deserve the Ph.D. 

Or we might respond to this dependency by feeling resentment:  That reviewer had no business reviewing my article, because he clearly doesn’t know the first thing about John Dewey!  My dissertation advisor is washed up and can’t even come up with a good idea for her second book; who is she to judge my work?  Social scientists and scientists have no idea what goes into writing humanistic scholarship; their feedback on my tenure file is completely irrelevant.

A lot of academic unhappiness is caused when one or both of these responses become our dominant response to our career dependence on the approval of others.  Here’s how I think this works:

Powerlessness encourages insecurity about the value of one’s work, and bewilderment about how academia works.  You may have heard someone say:  “I have no idea how I got this job; I don’t know the first thing about how to advise anyone else on the job market.”  “I don’t know how I got that article published in Journal X.  It’s just luck, I guess.”  “My committee probably let me defend because they were tired of having me around.”  “I’m the admissions mistake.  I have no idea why they let me into this Ph.D. program.”  This kind of response to dependency produces academics who think that they are here by mistake or chance, who believe they cannot advise or mentor others effectively because they see their success as a matter of chance, and who are diffident about their own abilities, no matter what their accomplishments.

Resentment encourages seeing other people as obstacles to our success, rather than viewing them as collaborators, colleagues, and friends.  You may have encountered a resentful colleague who fails to contribute to department service, or who makes passive aggressive comments in meetings, or who tries to draw you into conspiracy theories about the people who are out to get her.  Often the resentful academic takes full credit for her successes, but blames her failures on others.  “That reviewer just didn’t get how brilliant my article is!”  “The dean is out to get me because he is jealous!”  “My colleagues are all second-rate hacks.  They wouldn’t know a great work of scholarship if it hit them in the face!”  This kind of response produces academics who cannot play well with others, who thrive on and magnify negative situations, and whose willingness to mentor and advise can often seem contingent upon whether they perceive you as friend or foe.

Now I’ve painted two extreme caricatures here to try to suggest how these two common responses to our dependency as academics can contribute to deep unhappiness and dissatisfaction with our careers.  Fortunately, these are not the only ways we might respond to this dependency.

 

What is the antidote to powerlessness and resentment?  Celebration.

Academia is short on celebration.  Our career goals are often very long-term:  earning a Ph.D., getting tenure, publishing a book, etc.  Not only is the outcome something over which we do not have control, it also is really far away.  If we constantly defer celebrating until we have the Ph.D., the tenure-track job, the published book, or tenure, it could literally be years between celebrations.  That’s pretty depressing, frankly.

Moreover, when all we do is celebrate the final outcome of a particular milestone, we are actually increasing our dependency on the approval of others.  If I can’t celebrate submitting my first dissertation draft to my committee because they might not agree that I am ready to defend, then I am giving my committee not just the power to award me the Ph.D., but also the power to tell me when I have done something worthy of celebration.  If I can’t celebrate sending my book manuscript out to presses for review, then I am giving the editor and the book reviewers not just the power to offer me a contract, but also the power to tell me when I have done something worthy of celebration. 

You get to decide when you have done something worthy of celebration.  And if I were you, I would celebrate everything.  Every. little. thing.  Why the heck not?

If you celebrate what you have accomplished now, you take some of the emphasis off of the final outcome.  Think of it this way:  if you celebrate finishing a manuscript, no one can take that celebration away.  Not even if the manuscript is rejected by the journal you really wanted to see publish it.  You may not have the publication you wanted, but at least you didn’t miss the opportunity to celebrate finishing the manuscript in the first place.

Plus, it makes academic life more enjoyable.  Otherwise, you could be waiting for years to celebrate.  And in the meantime, you may be on pins and needles, feeling too powerless or resentful of your dependency on the approval of others to genuinely appreciate your accomplishments.

Celebration can look like whatever you want it to look like.  It might be throwing a party, posting an update on facebook, taking a day off, going on a dream vacation, enjoying a movie, or calling a loved one to tell them the good news.  Celebration is whatever will feel like celebration to you.

Celebrate when you send out a manuscript.  Celebrate when you get a book contract.  Celebrate when you have a good day of writing or teaching.  Celebrate when you handle a rejection well.  And of course, celebrate when you get the first copy of the book, the final tenure letter, your Ph.D., and that job offer. 

Academic life is a lot more humane when you celebrate frequently.  And, it turns out, frequent celebration makes you a lot less dependent on others for their approval.  They will still be gatekeepers, of course, and you will still get rejections.  But by owning and celebrating your accomplishments along the way, you acknowledge that you are not entirely powerless over your fate, even if you cannot control it.  And by owning and acknowledging your accomplishments for yourself, you attenuate your dependence on the approval of others, which alleviates the tendency to resent them for failing to grant it.

 

So try this on.  What do you have to celebrate today?

Thursday, November 7, 2013

Ask early, ask often: Gathering information about tenure expectations

[Note:  This is a post for junior faculty on a tenure-track.  The companion post for mentors of junior faculty is here.]


The reality of tenure and promotion is this:  many, many individuals sit in judgment on our files, each of whom may have her own take on what counts as excellence in different areas of our work.  Not only is there institutional variation, but there is individual variation as well.  It is dangerous, therefore, to plan for tenure based on what any one individual says the expectations are - because that person is just one of many who may have a say in the process!

What's worse, that one person could leave, retire, or go on sabbatical right when you are up for review, meaning that she won't be in the room having the discussion about the file you prepared to meet her specific expectations.  Or she may give you an accurate view of her expectations, but it may turn out she is something of an outlier when it comes to your department faculty as a whole.  Or your department itself could be out of sync with the rest of the college or university.  Or the expectations your colleagues set in your first years on the job could be outdated by the time you are up for tenure because of shifting standards.

The moral of the story is that you should ask as many people as you can about tenure standards, and you should ask the same people several times over the course of your pre-tenure time.  You may get different answers from the same person, which can feel frustrating.  [For example, I chaired a section at MPSA one year because a colleague told me I was expected to do that kind of service before tenure; at a later time, that same colleague denied ever having said such a thing!]  But you are better off feeling a little confused about what one person says because you asked them more than once (and maybe doing a little extra service to the profession), than submitting an unsuccessful tenure file based on outdated expectations set by that one person that have nothing to do with the expectations of a majority of senior faculty currently in your department/college/university.

So, ask the questions early on the tenure-track, but ask them often of many people, many times.

Getting information about tenure expectations is a long-term, iterative process.  This is not something you can cross off your list this week, this semester, or even this year.  Just keep it in the back of your head.  When you are out for coffee with a colleague, pop the question.  If you have an opportunity to meet with the provost, see if you can talk with her about tenure.

Who should you ask about tenure expectations?
  • all tenured faculty in your department, as well as any junior faculty who will likely be tenured by the time you come up.

  • new hires with tenure - faculty who started at another institution may bring in a set of norms that are at odds with what you have been working with so far.

  • tenured faculty outside your department - the more Full Professors, the better.  Ideally, you want to talk with faculty who have experiences with tenure cases like yours:  humanists, and humanist scholars housed in social science departments.  You may also want to talk with non-humanists about their expectations of humanist and/or political science tenure files. 

  • any faculty member you know with experience serving on college or university tenure and promotion committees - these people know what different kinds of tenure files look like, and they have experience with cases that are difficult or even denied.

  • administrators in key decision-making roles:  deans, provosts, chairs of tenure and promotion committees, people who know the insides of the process.


What should you ask them?
  • How does the process work?  When do I need to have my file ready?  What goes into my file?  What happens if there is a problem?  What are my rights and responsibilities?

  • What are the expectations for tenure?  (Ask specifically regarding research, teaching, and service.)

  • Why have cases had difficulty in the past?  (Problem cases here include not just ones that result in negative decisions, but cases that hit some kind of bump and do not just sail smoothly to their ultimate, positive outcome.)
    • in my department?
    • in the college/university?
    • at pre-tenure review?
    • at tenure review?
What you are looking for here is information about what happens when something goes wrong.  What can you learn from the problem cases?  What have your colleagues learned from these cases?

  • Would you be willing to review my file before I submit it?  (You surely don't want to ask this of everyone, but you might want to select a few, key people who can take a look at items like your research, teaching, and service statements.)

Wednesday, November 6, 2013

How to mentor for tenure from the outside in

[Note:  This is a post for mentors of junior faculty on a tenure-track.  The companion post for junior faculty mentees is here.]

One of the challenges of taking on a mentee who is not at your own institution is that you lack insider's information about how your mentee's institution works.  This is especially challenging in the case of mentoring junior faculty who are working towards tenure.  Tenure expectations, procedures, and norms vary widely from one place to the next.  Understandably, external mentors may feel unqualified to help their mentees navigate the idiosyncrasies of the tenure process at their home institutions.

However, external mentors can play a very important role in helping their mentees to collect information about how tenure and promotion work at their own colleges or universities.


Here's how this works: 

It is a rare department or school that has very clear, written expectations for tenure and promotion.  For example, some departments give junior faculty a specific number of peer-reviewed journals that they must publish, and even give them a list of journals in which they must publish.  In such cases, there may be no room for exceptions, but also no room for misinterpretation of what the standards are.

But in most cases, tenure and promotion expectations are pretty vague.  What is an "excellent" versus a "satisfactory" teaching record?  Do book chapters count if they are peer-reviewed?  Is it acceptable to publish a book with a relatively obscure press, if the book appears with a series that is prestigious in one's area; or is it better to publish with a more generally recognized press?  Does service require more than just serving on committees to which one has been assigned?  Is outreach valued, or regarded as an unnecessary distraction from research productivity?  Does the department recognize that theorists' research productivity often looks quite different from that of other political scientists?

The reality of tenure and promotion is this:  many, many individuals sit in judgment on our files, each of whom may have her own take on what counts as excellence in different areas of our work.  Not only is there institutional variation, but there is individual variation as well.  It is dangerous, therefore, to plan for tenure based on what any one individual says the expectations are - because that person is just one of many who may have a say in the process!


So, here's how you can help your mentee navigate the vagueness of the tenure process: 

1.  Assess what she already knows about tenure and promotion at her institution. 

Ask questions like:
  • How often are you reviewed before going up for tenure?  What are the expectations for these pre-tenure reviews?  For research?  Teaching?  Service?

  • What are the expectations for tenure?  For research?  Teaching?  Service?

2.  Now assess how much information she has gathered about tenure and promotion at her institution. 

Ask questions like:
  • How do you know that these are the expectations for pre-tenure and tenure review at your institutions?

  • Who have you talked with in your department about these expectations?

  • Who have you talked with outside your department about these expectations?

In some cases, you may discover that your mentee has very good information:  she has examined written documents about the process, she has spoken with a lot of people in and outside her department. 

In other cases, you may discover that your mentee is relying on information from just a few people - perhaps the chair of the department, or a senior theorist.  In such cases, you can encourage your mentee to cast her net more widely and strike up conversations about tenure expectations with more people. 

And - bonus! - you've just helped her to broaden her mentoring network by asking more people at her own institution to fill her in on the process.  You've turned a negative (your lack of knowledge about her institution) into a positive (an opportunity for her to become less dependent on you).


----------------

I'm curious:  how does this fit with your experience of the tenure process?  Are there other specific questions you would want your mentee to ask?  How did you get information about tenure and promotion when you were junior?  Send me an email or leave me a comment!